Indigo Tea Shop owner Theodosia Browning is attending the Heritage Societys Pirates and Plunder show when a histroy intern is murdered amidst the gold earrings and doubloons. Even with that on her plate, Theodosia still has to attend Charlestons Food and Wine Festival, where shes hosting a tea and cheese tasting. But as her thoughts keep drifting to the victim, Theodosia knows shell have to whet her investigative skills to find the killer among a schooner of suspects.